Conferring
A verb. To talk, engage in discussion, To have a conversation, Writer-to-writer. When I confer with writers I ask: “Who is this for?” “Why are you writing it?” Because if the response is, “You” and “To get a grade” I know we need to have a deeper conversation. Audiences should go beyond us teachers, And into the world, Where writers get response from readers, Who need/want/yearn to hear their thoughts. Purposes should go beyond getting a grade, And into the world, Where writers establish their own reasons to write, Because they need/want/yearn to share their thoughts. When I confer with writers I ask: “How can I help?” Because I want them to do the important work, Of recognizing what they need. It’s a different conversation when I say, “This is my teaching point.” When I say those words, I drive the conversation, And take agency away from the writer. And my job is to empower, not enable. When I confer with writers I ask: “What’s the one thing you’re trying to say with this piece?” Because a writer with a clear intention, Often has one important thing to say. And once the writer decides on that one thing, Revision becomes a clearer endeavor. When I confer with writers I ask: “How are you doing?” Because it’s my time to check in with them. To see them one-on-one. To make sure they are doing okay. To smile, laugh, comfort-- To listen. So, I can know the writer. When I confer, the blinds on the windows of my writers’ lives start to open and begin to reveal their inward selves. And, if I take the time to listen, to seek understanding, rather than offer a rote, robotic response, to ask, rather than declare, to be open, instead of asserting my agenda, Then I’m hearing the writer. And, to me, this is why conferring is essential.
9 Comments
3/14/2017 08:41:29 am
"When I confer, the blinds on the windows of my writers’ lives start to open..." This jumped out at me. Love this.
Reply
3/14/2017 08:42:04 am
I'm glad I stopped here! I'm giving PD on conferring on Friday, and I may start with this poem--I'll give you full credit! There's so much here to highlight and remember as we sit down with writers. Thank you!
Reply
Brian Kissel
3/14/2017 09:37:16 am
Absolutely! Feel free to use it! :) (Shameless plug alert!) I just came out with a new book and it's a found poem I created based on a chapter in that book: https://www.stenhouse.com/content/when-writers-drive-workshop.
Reply
3/14/2017 09:37:05 am
Wow, where to begin with this wonderful poem. First, I was struck by the power of this line: “What’s the one thing you’re trying to say with this piece?” I'm not entirely sure, but I think this will likely become a standard line of inquiry in all of my writing conferences from now on-- so thanks for that! Finally, I am in awe of how many ways you show how you teacher the writer and not the writing. Like Melanie, I would definitely want to share this poem in my future writing PD session-- if that is okay? Thank you for this gift!
Reply
Brian Kissel
3/14/2017 09:38:31 am
YES! Go for it! I just came out with a new book and I have a chapter on conferring in there. It's a found poem I created based on that chapter. :) https://www.stenhouse.com/content/when-writers-drive-workshop
Reply
3/14/2017 09:38:31 am
I love this poem on conferring, Brian. Please send it to Zsofi McMullen at Stenhouse to also publish on the Stenhouse blog. You say so many important things here - mainly, the teacher does most of the listening and the student should do most of the talking! Writers must take the lead in conferences, and our teaching point(s) comes from their needs - not some artificial march to a writing curriculum that was created in a one-size-fits-all view.
Reply
Brian Kissel
3/14/2017 09:39:40 am
Yes! Yes! Yes! It's a found poem I based off a chapter in the new book. It's all about the questions, isn't it? :)
Reply
Sonja Schulz
3/14/2017 09:38:09 pm
amazing poem. I love that you recognize that writers need readers.
Reply
Jennie B
3/14/2017 10:15:23 pm
I love it! The second to last stanza is perfect! Thanks for sharing!
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
About the Author
Brian Kissel is an Associate Professor of education at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte. His focus is writing instruction. He lives in North Carolina with his wife, Hattie and three kiddos: Charlie, Ben, and Harriet.
Archives
March 2018
Tags
|