Brian Kissel
  • Home
  • Brian's Books
  • Brian's Blog
  • Brian's Reads
  • Brian's YouTube Channel
  • Conference Handouts
  • Book Brian for PD
  • Brian's Brood

Those Who Know Do Not Speak

3/12/2018

3 Comments

 
Picture
Conferring requires the art of restraint:
   Teacher becomes student.
   Student becomes teacher.
Teacher learns to listen.

The teacher who knows,
   asks the just-right questions,
   to push their young writers,
Towards self-actualization.

Questions like:
    Why are you writing this?
    Who are you writing this for?
    How do you think they will react?

We don't know these answers:
     Teacher becomes student.
     Student becomes teacher.
Students teach us to listen.

The teacher who knows,
    takes a breath,
    waits a moment,
And uses writers' responses to formulate an idea.

After the writer speaks, the teacher speaks:
      "I have a thought,
       writer-to-writer, 
       you might want to try."  

The role of the teacher expands to:
     co-writer, co-reviser, co-editor,
     From a snippet of silence,
     Grows learning.

When we confer,
      we must first listen,
      before we speak because:
Those who know do not speak,
Those who speak do not know.
3 Comments
Deb Day link
3/12/2018 11:20:35 am

When I taught Creative Writing kids would at first get mad when sitting down for a writing conference. They just wanted me to tell them what to write or what to fix. It took them a while to get used to questions and thinking about their writing.

And this line, "I have a thought,
writer-to-writer,
you might want to try."
Is the reason I started writing again in the first place. I knew the struggles they were having because I had the same struggles at times. I gained credibility when we talked writer to writer.

Reply
Jennifer Laffin link
3/12/2018 11:32:25 am

"Teacher becomes student,
Student becomes teacher."

This is the one shift that needs to take place to really transform conferring. It will create a space where everyone - the teacher included -- had a role to play in building a community of writers.

I love that you wrote this post as a poem too. Thank you, Brian!

Reply
Jennifer Fletcher
3/12/2018 08:42:08 pm

Great post! This is what I love about conferring—I get to react with my reader brain instead of my teacher voice. It’s a treat to sit in the presence of a writer. Thank you for expressing these ideas so elegantly.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    About the Author

    Brian Kissel is an Associate Professor of education at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte.  His focus is writing instruction.  He lives in North Carolina with his wife, Hattie and three kiddos: Charlie, Ben, and Harriet.
    Picture
    Purchase
    Tweets by btkissel

    Archives

    March 2018
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017

    Tags

    All
    Brian's Bookshelf
    Personal
    Sketching
    Writing

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Brian's Books
  • Brian's Blog
  • Brian's Reads
  • Brian's YouTube Channel
  • Conference Handouts
  • Book Brian for PD
  • Brian's Brood